Halal ETFs vs Picking Your Own Stocks

How halal ETFs compare with building your own list: diversification, screening, downsides, and what still needs purifying and zakat.

Last updated Nov 14, 2026 · 2 min read

Should I buy a halal ETF or pick my own halal stocks?

An ETF gives you instant diversification and leaves the screening to someone else, while picking stocks gives you control but concentrates risk and takes work. Neither is more halal: what matters is the screen behind the holdings. This is education, not advice.

Halal ETFYour own halal stocks
DiversificationBuilt in: often hundreds of companiesYou build it, usually with far fewer
ScreeningDone by the fund's index and boardDone by you, and repeated each quarter
ControlNone over what is heldFull
CostA fund feeTrading costs and your time
MonitoringThe fund handles removalsYou re-screen and act

Many investors use both: a halal ETF as a core holding and a few individual stocks on top. Which fits you depends on your goals and how much time you want to spend, so this is a decision for you or an adviser.

Which halal ETFs are there?

Well-known US-listed examples are SPUS (SP Funds S&P 500 Sharia Industry Exclusions ETF) and HLAL (Wahed FTSE USA Shariah ETF), which follow different indexes, plus Wahed's global fund UMMA (Wahed Dow Jones Islamic World ETF). Check each fund's current fees and holdings with its issuer.

TickerFundIndex it follows
SPUSSP Funds S&P 500 Sharia Industry Exclusions ETFS&P 500 Shariah Industry Exclusions Index
HLALWahed FTSE USA Shariah ETFFTSE USA Shariah Index
UMMAWahed Dow Jones Islamic World ETFA Dow Jones Islamic index (see the issuer)

Index names are as reported by third-party sites and were not checked against the issuers' own pages, so confirm them with SP Funds and Wahed. Fees, holdings and performance change often, so they are left out here on purpose. This list is not a recommendation.

How do halal ETFs decide what to hold?

Each fund follows an index built with its own screening rules, so two halal ETFs hold different stocks and may differ from your own screen. Look at which index and screening standard a fund uses, and who certifies it, before you rely on it.

This is the same reason halal apps disagree, applied to funds: see why halal stock apps disagree. A fund built on one standard can hold a stock that another standard would reject. If you follow a particular standard, check that the fund's screen matches it.

What are the downsides of halal ETFs?

Fees are usually higher than for plain index funds, the screens remove whole sectors such as banks so the funds tend to lean toward technology and healthcare, and you cannot change what the fund holds. Some holdings may also sit close to screening limits.

None of these rules halal ETFs out, but they are worth weighing against buying individual stocks. Because a screen can change a fund's holdings when companies report, a fund can also trade more than a plain index fund.

Do I still purify and pay zakat on a halal ETF?

Usually yes. A halal ETF can still hold companies with a small share of impermissible income, so many investors purify the dividends it pays, and zakat applies to the fund as to other shares. For funds, many scholars accept 2.5% of net asset value.

Check whether the fund publishes a purification figure per share, and ask the issuer if it does not. Then see how to calculate dividend purification and how zakat applies to stocks and funds.

Sources

This article is educational. It is not investment advice and it is not a fatwa or religious ruling: scholars differ on some of these points, so ask a qualified scholar about your own situation.